To keep the forum more organized and less cluttered, we'll consolidate all the "help me re-roll" posts into one thread. If you've found an item and need help about what to re-roll, you can post here. Note that there are a few things you can do to help yourself, but also help us and the community to reduce the amount of work - so please read the following advice:
1) It's much better if you understand yourself what the best re-roll option is rather than just taking someone's advice. There are a couple of guides that will teach you the basics about what to re-roll; please take minute to look over them:
2) Re-rolls often depend on the build you're using or want to use in the future. A very quick way to find out what stats are desired on an item is to use our build tool, put in the item in question, and look into builds that people have created using that item. Most build creators state the desired stats for every item in the build guide - take a look and you might find the answer there!
3) If you can't find the information there or resolve the case yourself, feel free to post in this thread. Note that the more information you provide the better; sometimes re-roll advice cannot be given without sufficient control. Best case just post your character profile and say what build you're aiming for and what's your favorite playstyle.
4) We will move re-roll question threads into this thread to keep everything in one place. That being said, if we feel this thread is abused for showing off, we might also move the post to the RNG thread. Please don't show off here and only ask sincere questions!
Hi, can you guys help advice on what to reroll on this Gavel of Judgement? I imagine the two choices are either attack speed to life per fury spent, or rerolling the average damage to a better roll... Assuming I rolled LPFS on belt & bloodthirst passive what would be the best route with this, more damage or more healing?
@Fitsu: Hard to tell, I think there's no perfect option. Re-rolling IAs, vitality, or the damage range are all viable options imho. It's a nice one for sure, but unfortunately not perfect, and with the cube you should be able to get a better one in the next few months... so don't stress yourself out about it and go by gut feeling. I'd probably re-roll the IAS; I don't like re-rolling damage range since it locks you in and you can't switch to another stat later; and vitality is awesome for everything, it's a lot of vit, whereas IAS is not one of the top stats for HotA (afaik).
Moved to the re-roll thread. In the first post there's a link to a tool which let's you calculate whether re-rolling perfect damage or damage % will yield more DPS. If you don't care about solo you might also just roll LFPS to damage % since you don't need that (the monk will heal you), but in solo it's good to have on weapon.
geez. tons of gavel posts. Here's another! I'm can't decide which to use. On one hand I have lower average damage but high HoTA bonus. On the other hand I have higher average damage but low HoTA bonus. Which would you choose and how would you roll it?
geez. tons of gavel posts. Here's another! I'm can't decide which to use. On one hand I have lower average damage but high HoTA bonus. On the other hand I have higher average damage but low HoTA bonus. Which would you choose and how would you roll it?
The one on the left is better in my opinion.
I'd reroll vit to 10%dmg ---> you gonna get around 4k dps... slightly less than the other one but the 40% hota and +23 fury as secondaries make it a better choice
I totally agree. The extra 23 fury also provides 6% CHC using the HotA skill which is even more damage. However, none are ideal imo. For the time being go for the left and 10% Damage but re-roll the life per fury and not the VIT.
Moved to the re-roll thread. In the first post there's a link to a tool which let's you calculate whether re-rolling perfect damage or damage % will yield more DPS. If you don't care about solo you might also just roll LFPS to damage % since you don't need that (the monk will heal you), but in solo it's good to have on weapon.
If I rerolle Base DMG to max, I will have 3996.3 DPS.
If I rerolle +10% DMG, I will have 4108.6 DPS,
but will lose 1288 Vita or 2298 LPFS... My Gravel of Judgment
The one on the left is better in my opinion.
I'd reroll vit to 10%dmg ---> you gonna get around 4k dps... slightly less than the other one but the 40% hota and +23 fury as secondaries make it a better choice
I totally agree. The extra 23 fury also provides 6% CHC using the HotA skill which is even more damage. However, none are ideal imo. For the time being go for the left and 10% Damage but re-roll the life per fury and not the VIT.
Hi, so i've done some hellfire runs, and this is my best drop :
Physical skill deals 19% more damage
719 Str
10% crit
Weapons master passive.
Should i reroll the 19% phys damage for crit damage? I'm running Whirlwind barb.
Thanks
Moved to re-roll thread.
Usually my reply would be STR to CHD, but then I've heard that due to using CoE the physical damage isn't that useful, so your intuition would also be fine. Plus, if you re-roll physical damage you can use this for any element. However, as soon as you stop using CoE the physical damage is much much better than STR in any case. Well, tough choice. Wait for other replies.
Btw I solo play 98% Of the time and currently run ww with ignore pain so I'm not sure about surviablity with this build was waiting for ancient wow before switching builds.
To keep the forum more organized and less cluttered, we'll consolidate all the "help me re-roll" posts into one thread. If you've found an item and need help about what to re-roll, you can post here. Note that there are a few things you can do to help yourself, but also help us and the community to reduce the amount of work - so please read the following advice:
1) It's much better if you understand yourself what the best re-roll option is rather than just taking someone's advice. There are a couple of guides that will teach you the basics about what to re-roll; please take minute to look over them:
2) Re-rolls often depend on the build you're using or want to use in the future. A very quick way to find out what stats are desired on an item is to use our build tool, put in the item in question, and look into builds that people have created using that item. Most build creators state the desired stats for every item in the build guide - take a look and you might find the answer there!
3) If you can't find the information there or resolve the case yourself, feel free to post in this thread. Note that the more information you provide the better; sometimes re-roll advice cannot be given without sufficient control. Best case just post your character profile and say what build you're aiming for and what's your favorite playstyle.
4) We will move re-roll question threads into this thread to keep everything in one place. That being said, if we feel this thread is abused for showing off, we might also move the post to the RNG thread. Please don't show off here and only ask sincere questions!
Hi, can you guys help advice on what to reroll on this Gavel of Judgement? I imagine the two choices are either attack speed to life per fury spent, or rerolling the average damage to a better roll... Assuming I rolled LPFS on belt & bloodthirst passive what would be the best route with this, more damage or more healing?
Thanks.
imgupload
Ok I got an ancient Gavel of Judgement stats are:
1731-2146 Holy Damage
8% Damage
1363 strength
1250 Vitality (I need it for Toughness)
Could someone help me what would be the best to reroll?
Im 99.9% sure you get more damage from going to about 1900ish to 2400ish instead of getting 2% more dmg.
roll weapon damage range 1731-2146 if you need toughness
personally i would not waste this wep and roll vitality to area damage 24%
http://www.youtube.com/mannercookie
http://www.twitch.tv/mannercookie
6-7% damage reduction for sure. That's an insane chest, man.
@Fitsu: Hard to tell, I think there's no perfect option. Re-rolling IAs, vitality, or the damage range are all viable options imho. It's a nice one for sure, but unfortunately not perfect, and with the cube you should be able to get a better one in the next few months... so don't stress yourself out about it and go by gut feeling. I'd probably re-roll the IAS; I don't like re-rolling damage range since it locks you in and you can't switch to another stat later; and vitality is awesome for everything, it's a lot of vit, whereas IAS is not one of the top stats for HotA (afaik).
Pickup to ranged damage reduction I'd say. Or melee... but definitely either of those two.
Hallo,
What stat would you reroll?
The Gravel of Judgment
MyBarb
Hey
I presume you should roll Vita to % dmg.
However i am not sure how crucial LpFS is.
And what about reroll the dmg?
geez. tons of gavel posts. Here's another! I'm can't decide which to use. On one hand I have lower average damage but high HoTA bonus. On the other hand I have higher average damage but low HoTA bonus. Which would you choose and how would you roll it?
I totally agree. The extra 23 fury also provides 6% CHC using the HotA skill which is even more damage. However, none are ideal imo. For the time being go for the left and 10% Damage but re-roll the life per fury and not the VIT.
"Truth is like a lion. Don't try to defend it. Let it loose. It will defend itself" Augustine of Hippo
If I rerolle +10% DMG, I will have 4108.6 DPS,
but will lose 1288 Vita or 2298 LPFS...
My Gravel of Judgment
Thanks to both of you.
Usually my reply would be STR to CHD, but then I've heard that due to using CoE the physical damage isn't that useful, so your intuition would also be fine. Plus, if you re-roll physical damage you can use this for any element. However, as soon as you stop using CoE the physical damage is much much better than STR in any case. Well, tough choice. Wait for other replies.
Btw I solo play 98% Of the time and currently run ww with ignore pain so I'm not sure about surviablity with this build was waiting for ancient wow before switching builds.
Area dmg is the new hottneess I'd reroll the srt to crit dmg